After a car accident or other injury in California, many people get interventional pain care on a medical lien: the practice treats now and is paid from the settlement later. Lien bills are often several times what insurance would pay, and three California Supreme Court and appellate decisions decide how much of that bill a jury can see.
Three cases that set the rules
Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions
An insured plaintiff can recover past medical damages only up to the lesser of the amount actually paid or incurred and the reasonable value of the care. The full billed amount does not count if insurance paid less.
Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics
A plaintiff who has insurance but chooses to treat outside it on a lien is treated as uninsured. The full billed lien amount can come into evidence, as long as it is shown to be reasonable.
Qaadir v. Figueroa
Unpaid lien bills are admissible to show reasonable value, but the defense can cross-examine about attorney referral relationships and challenge reasonableness with local fee benchmarks.
Billed lien vs. reasonable-value benchmarks
Medicare and commercial plans pay roughly $300 to $1,500 for an epidural depending on the site. Lien-based interventional pain charges in California frequently reach $5,000 to $15,000 or more per injection series. That gap is what gets argued at mediation and trial. The table below shows the benchmarks a defense expert is likely to use for a surgery-center procedure in Los Angeles and Orange Counties, and the typical gross lien range.
| Procedure (ASC) | Medicare benchmark | Commercial benchmark | Typical gross lien bill |
|---|---|---|---|
| CPT 62323Interlaminar ESI | $541 | $758–$1,299 | $2,166–$4,872 |
| CPT 64483Transforaminal ESI | $637 | $892–$1,529 | $2,549–$5,735 |
| CPT 64493Facet / medial branch block | $606 | $849–$1,455 | $2,425–$5,457 |
| CPT 64635Facet radiofrequency ablation | $1,189 | $1,665–$2,854 | $4,756–$10,701 |
| CPT 27096SI joint injection | $619 | $867–$1,486 | $2,477–$5,574 |
Medicare = CY 2026 professional plus estimated ASC facility fee, LA & Orange locality. Commercial = 1.4×–2.4× Medicare. Lien range = 4×–9× Medicare, the common California range. Single level.

Checklist for injured patients
- Get a copy of the lien agreement and read who is responsible if the case does not settle.
- Ask for itemized bills with CPT codes, levels and the site of service.
- Ask whether the facility fee is billed by a separate surgery center under its own lien.
- Keep records of how each injection changed your pain and function; that documentation supports both care and the claim.
Checklist for plaintiff attorneys and case managers
- Expect a Pebley election question: does the client have insurance, and why was it not used?
- Prepare for Qaadir cross on referral relationships between the firm and the treating practice.
- Benchmark each CPT code against Medicare and commercial rates for the treating locality before demand.
- Confirm the medical necessity trail: radicular findings and imaging for epidurals, two diagnostic blocks before RFA.
Benchmark a lien procedureLien-ready specialist inquiries
Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. (2011) 52 Cal.4th 541; Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics, LLC (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1266; Qaadir v. Figueroa (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 790. This page is general information, not legal advice.